Scieszka, Jon. 1989. THE TRUE STORY OF THE 3 LITTLE PIGS!. Ill.
by Lane Smith. New York: Viking Penguin. ISBN: 978-0140544510
2. Plot Summary
This version of THE THREE LITTLE PIGS is retold by Jon
Scieszka as a first person tale from the viewpoint of A. Wolf (The Big Bad
Wolf) and how he has been framed of committing the crimes of eating the first
two pigs and trying to eat the third. A. Wolf guides you through his story from
the beginning when he was making a cake for his sweet old granny all the way to
how he ended up in jail being framed by the media as a really bad guy.
3. Critical Analysis
Jon Scieszka does a great job of writing as the wolf and speaking
out as the innocent neighbor just seeking out a cup of sugar and getting caught
in some bizarre situations and misunderstandings. The writing is straight
forward, but there is a hint of embellishment and a sense that the wolf is not
telling the whole truth when he “accidentally” kills two of the pigs and
instead of calling the police to explain he instead eats the pigs because “It
seemed like a shame to leave a perfectly good ham dinner lying there in the
straw.” The illustrations are cartoonish and in darker shades of color to give
the feel of a memory being experienced firsthand.
4. Review Excerpts
NEW YORK TIMES: “It is a kind of revisionist history in that
it is told by one Alexander T. Wolf”
5. Connections
The story of THE THREE LITTLE PIGS is one that spans ages
and this version would be great to read out loud and use to help young readers
identify a writing style that may be new to them.
Shaskan, Trishia Speed. HONESTLY, RED RIDING HOOD WAS
ROTTEN! THE STORY OF LITTLE RED RIDNG HOOD AS TOLD BY THE WOLF.
Trivizas, Eugene. THE THREE LITTLE WOLVES AND THE BIG BAD
PIG. ISBN: 0-689-81528-X
No comments:
Post a Comment